One Last Thing

Before the weekend begins. Zion National Park has released what seems (but is not specified as) it’s final draft backcountry management plan. What stood out to me, after slogging through the 88 pages, was the extent to which it doesn’t change the status quo. And that is, I think, for the most part okay. The backcountry of Zion is for the most part in pretty good shape.

The numbers are interesting. While total park visitors have remained essentially stagnant for the previous 8 years (around 2.5 million a year), the number of users in the backcountry has increased from 11,000 to 27,000, and the number of “Narrow Canyon Day Users” (ie, canyoneers and Narrows hikers) increased from 4,500 to almost 19,000 in the same eight year period. (See Table 19, page 64)

What does change is the number of permits, and the size of groups allowed, in certain canyon zones. The Zion Canyoneering Coalition (ie Tom Jones of Imlay Canyon Gear) has an interesting analysis of the research methods used to determine these limits.


Here’s the most illuminating selection of data they took on group size.

I remember filling out one of their mail surveys a year (or two?) ago, and was grateful then that they asked users. Flaws or no, I think smaller groups represent a step in the right direction, though they also raise the daily limit of the Subway from 50 to 80, which is in my opinion unwise. That poor canyon is already quite scary enough.

My letter will be sent off shortly, though I won’t emphasize what I think is one of the saving graces of any such government management issue: that outside the “prime” season one will still find solitude, even in the most publicized of backcountry locals.

The Subway in February is quite lovely, and I’m hatching plans for a Narrows hike around Christmas.

3 responses to “One Last Thing”

  1. Yet you forget- even in February we did run into another party in The Subway- and typical for that canyon- an ill-equipped and uncertain party.The worst idiocy I’ve ever seen in canyons has always been in that one. I’m not nearly as fond of secrecy and whatnot as some members of the community- I think everyone should have the chance to get out there- but then I end up surprised at how someone can get themselves in there with so little information as to what they’ll be encountering once they are. And worse yet- take others, particularly young adults, in with them.So be it. Let’s just hope they reduce those limits.

  2. On the subject of Zion, I hope the fire does not fill some of the canyons with dirt and debris. That happened down here with some of the canyons on Mt Lemon (Tucson area) after two such fires. Dakota Hill Fire: http://mattmaxon.homeip.net/data/Fire%20Perimters/2007/dakota_hill_complex/DAKOTA_HILL_COMPLEX%202007_07_19%20GEOMAC%20PERIMETER.pdf

  3. I was just in the subway (Das Boot) and I was a little ashamed at how many side trails there are in the area. That said, if we raise the max on some of these canyons, we should also think about doing more service projects, like trail upkeep, etc.

Leave a reply to Meredith Cancel reply