My favorite shoes

This fall I’ve been wearing little other than the Astral TR1 Merge, and for the sort of walking I like to do these days, they are far and away the best pair of shoes I’ve ever had.


While they don’t have a tremendous number of miles on them, almost all of those miles have been off trail.  They went elk hunting in the Montana prairie badlands, did an alpine traverse on broken granite, went hiking, biking, and climbing in the Colorado Plateau, and have spent more time bushwacking and traversing limestones ridges close to home.  All of those are more abusive on shoes than average, in their own way, and the shoes are holding up perfectly thus far.

Traction across mediums has been excellent.  The lugs grip loose soil, either straight on or sidehill, while having enough surface area for good friction on bare rock.  The rubber is soft enough, without wearing too fast.  The midsole is thick and protective enough, without any hinge points, and without feeling unnatural or slow.  They’re supportive enough, for me, for technical mountain biking using flat pedals, but I can tolerate far softer shoes in all areas than most.  Significantly, the modest padding and added material in the heel and toebox have improved both hold and protection; I’ve not experienced any of the unpleasant talus bites I got often in the Brewers.  The only real flaw is the open mesh used in the toungue, which extends down into the toebox just enough to become a magnet for cheatgrass seeds and a conduit for sand.


For me, they’ve been supportive enough to carry a 70 pound pack on a few occasions (deer pack out, as well as a family backpack load with a toddler on top).  For me and my feet, support means  enough padding and structure to insulate my feet from the terrain, even when I’m suddenly 50% again my own weight, while being pliable enough to not cause hot spots.  Zero drop is a big part of the later, as is the lack of illusory things like ankle support.  The Merges work for me because they’re a coherent package, the level of support, degree of structure, even the sole and rubber all working to serve one particular style of walking.

That style is a light footed one, based on balancing over terrain and using weaknesses and variations for purchase.  Smearing across the loose wet sidehill, rather the kicking steps.  Working the stable pieces of a talus slope, rather than digging through and into the loosest parts to make steps.  This style is as much about strength and ability as it is about the type and style of trip.  People who regularly take big packs into rough terrain are more often drawn to stiff boots due to pace, and indeed due to their line through a place.  This isn’t to say that fast line, fluid pace shoes are not compatible with a big pack, simply that melding such shoes with a heavy pack requires more than simple strength.  It requires a skillset, and that combination is due to how learning conventionally evolves has historically been uncommon.

That is changing, and as fluid line choice under expedition conditions works further toward the norm, I hope shoes like the Merge remain around as options.


7 responses to “My favorite shoes”

  1. Interesting post. I bought some Brewers after looking at them because of you. I could never use them like you do though. They are great shoes I’ve loved for paddleboarding and short hikes to play in rivers and waterfalls. But I couldn’t use them comfortably for steep terrain or heavy loads. They just don’t have enough structure, and while I could make do with the underfoot stiffness/protection, I prefer a rock plate.

    For reference, the La Sportiva Ultra Raptors are ideal for me, in terms of structure, protection and underfoot stiffness…I could stand for less stack height. I think the Bushidos would be perfect, but they are way too narrow for my Fred Flintstone foot.

    The Astral sole compound is fantastic in terms of grip though. Really love that, and the neutral balance and wider toe box is lovely. So much so I picked up a pair of their hemp canvas shoes as daily beaters.

    1. The Merge’s certainly have more support than the Brewers, but the two shoes live very much in the same universe. Being able to take either on a serious off trail endeavor is the end product of a ~decade of using ever less obtrusive shoes for everything.

  2. I spend more time than most walking off-trail, working full-time doing layout for and construction of trails. I have a similar approach to (fully engaged) hiking technique and (minimalist) footwear, and find simple pull-on Blundstone boots work well for me. The smooth lace-less profile also helps when bush-bashing, and simplifies water proofing. I recently had comprehensive base-line assessment done by my athletic therapist, and after 20 years of this approach I was found to have exceptional foot stability and strength, which apparently is foundational (more than just metaphorically) to athletic performance.

  3. Have you ever stumbled upon the Salomon Jungle Ultra Boot?
    I considered it but went with my tried and true Haix. Gore tex has it’s advantages for day-hiking and low milage days with the kids, but I am very interested in the Salomon boot as Gore-tex always seems to fade away with time and then you just have a slow-drying boot.
    (This conversation excludes running shoes, I do use them for my own higher milage, non-fridgid trips. Scope: camping > milage.)

    1. Never seen those, they look cool! The 11mm drop is more than I can really tolerate these days, and going back decades the Salomon midsole shape has never really worked with my foot. Nice to see more tough, non-waterproof options.

      1. Oops, I didn’t care to look at that. 11 is more on plenty side, but for higher loads it’s not so bad. I normally use trail runners: Merrel Trail glove or New balance minimus 10.

  4. […] These are still my favorite shoes ever, but a whole lot of abrasive desert mud the past few months has revealed a serious design flaw; the webbing lace loop over the instep.  By a month ago, three of the four had cut through.  This is a big deal, as on these relatively floppy shoes that tension holding the heel down is vital for foot stabilization.  Something had to be done. […]

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s